People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Very small but always very busy. They make it fresh for you they might look young (the cooks) but they make a d@#m good pizza. Nice and warm pizza, slightly crunchy pepperoni. Just overall great. ”
“ We bring 35 - 40 people every year to Pizza Plus while at our drill competition at the wonderful Diamond Bar Arena. The employees at Pizza Plus are wonderful. The food is great, the service is excellent. We will be back if they will have us. Lol ”
“ This was recommended by a local but it took us years to stop by. On our way back home from our kids competition in Modesto, we made the stop and it was a great choice. This pizza was great and delicious. We will definitely stop again and try out more of their specialty pizzas. Just and note, lost of local, this is in a small town and once you walk in everyone will stare lol, but then they don't, just one of those things when you walk in, I think they just expect locals. Either way, the pizza was good, the place was nice, and the service was great. ”
“ We rented one of the banquet rooms for a special event. Food was excellent, service was great, and the atmosphere was what you'd expect for a pizza joint. Great salad bar!! ”
“ I don't know why you're checking reviews just go! I was recommended this spot and man do I regret not coming in sooner. The pizza is loaded with fresh toppings, the cheese is very stringy, and well cooked. The crust, and bottom is crunchy, its dough is soft along with well loaded sauce and cheese. The wings are very well breaded, the sauce is on the side, but it gets covered very well when dipped. ”
“ Pizza plus. Man. What a great pizza place. I used to go to the Patterson location and then it closed. Newman was good. They changed their recipe for some reason. But The hilmar location is super delicious still. Just like the old pizza plus used to be. Imma go here from now on! Staff was great and friendly. Food was amazing. Cooks all said hi to me. Store was clean. Can’t ask for anything more. Good job hilmar pizza plus! ”
“ My son has been having his birthday party here for the past few years. Best pizza ever he says amazing. Customer service would recommend 110% love love ”
“ We didn't have to wait long at all. Great customer service. Inside was clean, pizza place atmosphere, and I enjoyed the football game on the screen. Pizza was delicious. Overall I enjoyed my visit and will for sure return to watch another game. ”
Menu
Half Sandwich & Salad
US$12.502 Liter
US$4.25Roast Beef Sandwich
Canadian Bacon Sandwich
Salami Sandwich
About
Pizza Plus - Hilmar
Welcome to Pizza Plus - Hilmar, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Hilmar, California, at 19935 American Ave. This bustling pizza joint is renowned not just for its delicious pies but also for the vibrant atmosphere and dedication to quality that permeates every inch of its small, yet welcoming space.
With a phone number of +1 209-634-6200, Pizza Plus is always ready to greet customers with sizzling, fresh-made pizzas that draw both locals and visitors alike. This establishment is celebrated for its willingness to cater to groups, making it a beloved spot for annual gatherings like drill competitions, drawing in crowds of 35-40 people who consistently rave about the exceptional service and delightful food.
At Pizza Plus - Hilmar, the star of the show is undoubtedly the pizza. Customers are captivated by the slightly crunchy pepperoni, abundant fresh toppings, and perfectly cooked cheese that meld deliciously atop a crunchy, soft crust. Reviews from satisfied patrons like Edgar Nieto highlight the exemplary quality across all offerings, from their savory wings to the indulgent pizzas loaded with flavor and freshness.
The menu offers a variety of side orders that complement the main event brilliantly, including garlic bread and pizza bread options that are perfect for sharing or indulging alone. For those looking for a healthy touch, the all-you-can-eat salad bar is an amazing steal at $9.25, enabling you to balance your meal with crisp, fresh veggies.
Don’t forget to save room for dessert! The Pizzookie and Root Beer Float are sweet finishes that encapsulate the joy of a great meal. As reflected in customer reviews, such as the one from Stephanie Ruiz, the warm, inviting pizzas are consistently revered, making every visit a rewarding experience.
In essence, Pizza Plus - Hilmar is more than just a pizza place; it's a community staple where food is prepared with care, and service is paramount. Each visit feels like a homecoming, showcasing an unwavering commitment to quality that keeps patrons returning for more. So, if you haven't yet experienced the magic of Pizza Plus, what are you waiting for? Dive into a culinary adventure that promises delightful bites and a wonderful time!
Book a table